Right off the bat, I think women who say they need abortions for health reasons are full of it. Prove me wrong. I encourage you to use all the proof and real-life examples you can. Also, if ya’ll have the time, tell me why they just can’t remove the baby by C-section and put it on life support, so that way, both the baby and the woman have a chance to live.
If I was a doctor, would I be asking this question? Think people.
Wow. "…a baby is basically like a parasite that feeds off of society for a long time until it becomes self-sufficient." Yup, that just makes your answer all the more convincing. I appreciate the example, but not that comment. Try to remember that you were a parasite once and be glad your parents didn’t abort your sorry behind.
AND, who the hell says all women are sufficient? Are the crack whores sufficient?
I read what you wrote Elizabeth, quite clearly. I realize some women have medical problems that require abortion. Yet no one who answered this question has told me exactly what conditions make abortion a needed choice for survival except for hmasson. I haven’t much time in my schedule to do the research, that’s why I posted this question. I needed extra help finding the facts. But it looks like some people of the women’s health section either don’t know or just want to be useless. I wanted sources for doctor’s say on the matter; instead, I mostly got people’s opinions, NOT what I asked for. I appreciate the statistics you gave, though, Elizabeth, I would have just liked a source as well.
I’m sorry for getting edgey on you hmasson. It’s just that when you made that comment, it sounded as though you were the kind if person who would practice infanticide or something. I understand your point about the essentiality of women, but these essential women don’t appear out of thin air. How can you say that you stole your mother’s kidney? My mother used to tell me that she would jump in front of bullet to save me. Should I blame myself for stealing my mother’s life if she would have done that? Guilt has a way of making people feel less worthy than they are. If I understand you right, it’s what’s going on with you. You think that your medical difficulties have made you a thorn in your family’s side. But didn’t they give you the treatment? The kidney? We aren’t animals. You can argue that, scientifically, we are, but in spirit, we are above this game of survival of the fittest. We have medicine, science; we don’t just let people die. I understand the need for a woman to survive.
I just want the reasons so that I don’t have to feel any malice towards women who are actually sick, and can’t keep a baby. In my mind, I need to separate them from the women/girls who carelessly get pregnant and eliminate the unwanted baby, because for them, I feel no pity.
I understand Alda. I realize you have a very deep love and appreciation for life, and I respect that. I was considering reposting this question elsewhere, but I’ve decided against it. Honestly, I don’t think anyone is sure about the medical circumstances that eliminate a fetus or, at least sure when these circumstanes are genuinely come into play. Before medicine, many women died in childbirth. Nowadays, the death rates during childbirth have decreased dramatically, so it’s really hard for the women to determine, in my opinion, whether the child is either life-threatening or just inconvenient, because in her mind, she wants to get rid of this baby as soon as it presents a serious problem. Pregnancy is stressful enough, so a difficult pregnancy is not something women want to go through. Yet, some are willing. Sure, doctors know, but they can only suggest things, not enforce them.

God, this detail page got long. X(
If Namaste ever comes back (which I doubt) this question was straight up about health. YOU made it an issue about morals, not me. Putting a bit of my opinion on the detail page did not give anybody the right to go off on me. If they really needed to though, they needed to give me a decent answer first, then rant. Honestly, I doubt you know what you’re talking about. Yes, you know that if a fetus threatens the mother’s life, the doctor would recommend an abortion, but that’s obvious, and, I think, about all you know. The rest of your answer is opinion. No fact (accept your personal experience, in which you didn’t even tell me what condition they were in) and mostly opinion. Okay, I’m done now.
A somebody tell Madame to edit her lame-*ss answer.
(Correction: ^ *And*) Okay, really done now.

I had a kidney transplant a year and a half ago and right now I’m still taking a lot of anti-rejection medications, steroids, and other medications. Being pregnant would put stress on my body, especially since I’ve already had so many surgeries in my abdominal area. My new kidney is right by my uterus, so I don’t know what effect that would have on me or the growing fetus. Neprologists and transplant surgeons have told me that they only recommend that a woman who has had a kidney transplant only have one child, and even then it is an extremely high risk pregnancy. Also, the medications that I’m on cause kidney damage and other problems in the fetus, so even if I did give birth, a whole new set of problems would arise. I don’t want to put a newborn through everything I went through, it’s just unfair in my mind. C-sections are still risky procedures, and if the baby might not live even if it had to be born prematurely. Also, premature babies have complications even when they’re mothers aren’t on medications.
It’s really none of your business, and I’m sure other women have completely relevant health reasons for having an abortion. Personally, I think a woman has the right to choose and is spending that much money (ie: surgery costs, medical bills for the rest of the babies life) and personal costs (the mother becoming sick or the baby becoming sick) really necessary when a woman could just reproduce in other ways that weren’t so risky (surrogate mothers)? The woman is typically already a benefit to society and can pull her own weight, while a baby is basically like a parasite that feeds off of society for a long time until it becomes self-sufficient. Thank God I don’t want kids in the first place.
Edit: I realized when I made that comment that it would probably make somebody angry, but what do you expect from a 19 year old. With all the medical problems I put my family through (and yes it’s probably weird that I view it that way because it wasn’t my fault) I do feel like a parasite. I stole my mom’s kidney! What I meant by that was that woman can usually carry viable children after an abortion/miscarriage. It’s not usually the end of fertility so I view a woman as the more valuable aspect to society. And no, I don’t think all woman are productive, that’s why I said "typically". Not all men are productive either.
Anyway, sorry about that. Sometimes it’s difficult to communicate over the internet.

  1. bebekaychic says:

    Its not ur business if the doctors decide its for the best for the mother to abort then she can if she wants..Worry about YOUR life..
    References :

  2. Namaste says:

    Honestly it really depends. If the woman is in danger of loosing her life, she has the the decision to decide whether she wants to save the babies life or not. Now, don’t think that this is an easy desicion, by far it is not. To say that they are "full of it" is quite frankly, very rude. I know a woman who had to make the decision herself. It was a tough decision. Are you a doctor? No. Just because you get a C-section, doesn’t necissarily mean the baby will live. At times, it can, but in some situations (the woman I knew) their was no hope.

    Your question is a question of morals, not a health issue.

    Edit: I agree with what the woman below said, but I don’t know where you get your facts. In some situations, it is unfortunate but their are medical problems that effect the health of the mother. It’s wrong, I agree, but in some lifethreatening situations I can see why they would choose that. Once again, it is a question of morals. Not health.
    References :

  3. elizabeth b says:

    I heard recent testimonies that it is never the mothers health concerns to abort. 90 percent of abortions are purely elective. Most abortions are done on healthy mothers and babies. i think if you don’t want children you should have a hysterectomy or take precautions not to get pregnant it is not the child’s fault so it should never be taken out on it. I think anyone who has had an elective abortion should be shunned from society. Most babies can be born at 24 weeks and survive with help. My daughter was born at 29 weeks and she is fine. People that wait that long to have an abortion Should be charged with murder. They have stricter laws on animal cruelty than the do on killing babies. A fetus at that age can feel pain and experience sadness and happiness.

    If you read my answer you would see that it says 90 percent are elective. I did not say all of them were. If you would read testimonies from the Dr’s that do this you would know also. Do alittle more research on the subject. Read the court documents on the abortion ban act.
    References :

  4. hmasson28 says:

    I had a kidney transplant a year and a half ago and right now I’m still taking a lot of anti-rejection medications, steroids, and other medications. Being pregnant would put stress on my body, especially since I’ve already had so many surgeries in my abdominal area. My new kidney is right by my uterus, so I don’t know what effect that would have on me or the growing fetus. Neprologists and transplant surgeons have told me that they only recommend that a woman who has had a kidney transplant only have one child, and even then it is an extremely high risk pregnancy. Also, the medications that I’m on cause kidney damage and other problems in the fetus, so even if I did give birth, a whole new set of problems would arise. I don’t want to put a newborn through everything I went through, it’s just unfair in my mind. C-sections are still risky procedures, and if the baby might not live even if it had to be born prematurely. Also, premature babies have complications even when they’re mothers aren’t on medications.
    It’s really none of your business, and I’m sure other women have completely relevant health reasons for having an abortion. Personally, I think a woman has the right to choose and is spending that much money (ie: surgery costs, medical bills for the rest of the babies life) and personal costs (the mother becoming sick or the baby becoming sick) really necessary when a woman could just reproduce in other ways that weren’t so risky (surrogate mothers)? The woman is typically already a benefit to society and can pull her own weight, while a baby is basically like a parasite that feeds off of society for a long time until it becomes self-sufficient. Thank God I don’t want kids in the first place.
    Edit: I realized when I made that comment that it would probably make somebody angry, but what do you expect from a 19 year old. With all the medical problems I put my family through (and yes it’s probably weird that I view it that way because it wasn’t my fault) I do feel like a parasite. I stole my mom’s kidney! What I meant by that was that woman can usually carry viable children after an abortion/miscarriage. It’s not usually the end of fertility so I view a woman as the more valuable aspect to society. And no, I don’t think all woman are productive, that’s why I said "typically". Not all men are productive either.
    Anyway, sorry about that. Sometimes it’s difficult to communicate over the internet.
    References :

  5. Alda says:

    There, to me, is not a reason…I would lay my life on the line for my child…I had a hard time giving birth to both of my children…I would not trade anything for it….Health wise, I figure that if God gave me the child then He already knew the end result…my opinion, and I will forever stand by it.
    References :
    Ok will add. you said you are looking for reasons not to feel malice…I have a seriously hard time with anyone taking a life. So I cannot obviously help here. Women are not supposed to be garbage cans and someone "taking out the trash." I do understand when it is life threatening but with that excuse will come a bunch more excuses for aborting a fetus. My opinion and I stand by it…take care and good luck with this one…I agree with you but cannot put it in the words you are asking for.

    Hey it is me again…I did a report in college on abortion..It was horrible..the "trash" outside the clinics..I am not going there. I applaud you for having the guts to ask AND stand by your question. Not many on here will do that, they are hit and run…take care my friend…there are not many like you left. Alda

    Back real quick…does anyone realize how many beautiful people are on this planet because they were not "trashed." I have friends with beautiful children that they were told to terminate because of possible complications. Take care (again) Alda

  6. madame says:

    Its none of your business, and no one has to justify their decision with to people like you.

    YOU are wrong.
    References :